Mystery Item
Mystery Item
Mystery Item
Mystery Item
Mystery Item
Mystery Item
Mystery Item

Mystery Item

97 reviews
Regular price $12 ❤️ Free shipping $100+
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Only 269 in stock!


Everyone loves a good mystery! Trust in us and let us surprise you with a one of a kind Mystery Item! Starting at just $8, you could get a Girls Crew exclusive piece that isn't available on our website! The more you buy, the more unique the pieces become! What are you waiting for? Your Mystery Item is waiting for you!

    • Products shown are examples of what are available for purchase but may not be what you receive
    • Mystery Items will vary from customer to customer. Purchasing a Mystery Item does not mean you'll receive a piece of jewelry. You could receive a ring, pair of earrings, piercing style earring, bracelet, necklace, anklet, hair claw, or magnetic earring
    • Jewelry is 18k gold plated, 18k rose gold plated, or rhodium plated over brass
    • Cubic zirconia stones or other synthetic stones
    • Other materials include enamel, beads, or acrylic
    • $15+ pieces have full protective coating
  • Rings are slightly adjustable and recommended for sizes 6-8
  • Sold as a single item!
  • Mystery Items are final sale!

Please let us know which color you prefer in the notes section. The notes section is only available on the cart page. 

Please note that this does not guarantee you will receive an item based on your choice, but we will do our best to choose items based on your preference.


Wrap a piece of string around the base of your finger and record the measurement in millimeters. Use the chart below to find your size given the closest measurement.

Common ring sizes for women are 6 (16.5 mm) and 7 (17.3 mm).

Size Diameter Circumference
4 14.99 mm 47 mm
4.5 15.25 mm 48 mm
5 15.7 mm 49.3 mm
5.5 16.1 mm 50.6 mm
6 16.5 mm 51.9 mm
6.5 16.92 mm 53.1 mm
7 17.32 mm 54.4 mm
7.5 17.73 mm 55.7 mm
8 18.14 mm 57 mm
8.5 18.54 mm 58.3 mm
9 18.95 mm 59.6 mm
9.5 19.35 mm 60.8 mm


 Chain Length Fit
12" - 14"
Fits just above collar bone
16" - 18"
Fits at collar bone
Fits in middle of chest
Fits at cleavage
Fits below cleavage
Free Standard Shipping on all U.S. Orders over $100
Free & Easy Returns details
Questions? Check out out our FAQ or Contact Us

With the proper care, your Girls Crew jewelry can last a long time.

Sterling Silver Care: Sterling silver jewelry can be passed down from generation to generation with the right care. We encourage you to wear your silver everyday! Silver that is used regularly needs less care. In rare cases, silver can tarnish when it is exposed to salt, air, and products containing sulfur. But no need to worry, we offer cleaning services!

Gold Filled / Gold/Rose Gold Vermeil / Gold/Rose Gold/Rhodium Plated: We encourage you to remove your jewelry before showering, exercising and swimming. Gold Filled, Vermeil & Plated jewelry can tarnish when in contact with perfumes, lotions or hair products. Please avoid harsh chemicals such as bleach, oil, jewelry cleaners, or polishing cloths, this can affect the finishing. To help keep your jewelry looking beautiful, store it in a Girls Crew dust bag, sealed plastic bag or dry cloth bag.

Piercing Style Earrings - Surgical Steel with Gold Plated over Brass Pendant: These earrings have a surgical steel post and ball backing making it perfect for those with mild skin sensitivity. Please note that the pendant is 18k gold, 18k rose gold, or rhodium plated over brass and can cause slight irritation for those with moderate or very sensitive skin. Please remove before showering, swimming, working out, etc. Read the recommendations above for plated jewelry for more info. 

Solid Gold: Solid gold (10k, 14k gold) is a precious metal that will not oxidize or discolor since it is the least reactive metal. The 14k alloy gives our pieces their beautiful, subtle hue. It is also an active lifestyle’s best friend; it scratches less and doesn’t bend or wear out as easily as 18k.

  • Even something as strong as 14k solid gold deserves some loving. To maintain its beauty, scrub lightly with a toothbrush and warm water.
Customer Reviews
4.8 Based on 97 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
Rachael W.
United States

You really will get not what you expected

I specified I wanted silver, it was gold and not at all my style. They made an exception and let me return it.

United States United States

Unexpected Surprise!

Not knowing what the item is, is already a surprise. But when I got the item, it was on my wishlist and I actually waiting to purchase it! Lovely surprise and a great way to add an element of excitement once you get it!

United States United States

Mystery item

Beautiful earrings

United States United States

Mystery item $15

Cute tiny studs

Sara S.
United States United States

Love it!!! <3

i got the $15 option and i love it so much. They're these cute little flower studs that have a pink/purple colour. They're so shiny!! it's honestly not something i would've picked out for myself but ig that's the good thing about the mystery item :) i never would've had these earrings that i rlly love. i think they will go v nicely with a lot of other earrings 10/10 can't wait to buy this again!